2509 S New Jersey Street
 More Photos

2509 S New Jersey StreetIndianapolis, IN 46225


Pending
$130,000
Asking Price
3
Bd
2
Ba
2,280
Sqft
0.13
Ac Lot

2509 S New Jersey Street Indianapolis, IN 46225


Single Family Property Type
12 daysTime pending
$57Price per sqft
1 carGarage
1926Year Built
Basement
Great investment opportunity right near Garfield Park! Jump on it!

Approximate location on a geospatial gridSouth Central Indy
Icon
Adventures
in Nature
Icon
Established
Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Buyer Blueprint

The plan that gets you home.

Learn More

Year Built

1926

City

Indianapolis

Type

Single Family Residence

Neighborhood

Garfield Park

County

Marion

Lot Size

0.13 ac / 5,489 sqft

Bedrooms

3

Full Bathrooms

2

Half Bathrooms

0

Garage Capacity

1

Living Area Total

2,280 sqft

Price per sqft

$57.02

Living Area Main & Upper

1,464 sqft

Connect with a Dwellane Agent

Like what you see? Our trusted agents are ready to help you take the next step.

Listing Agent

Joe Everhart
317-916-1052

Co-Listing Agent

Quinn Demaree
317-701-0479

Buyer Agent

Listing Provider

Everhart Studio, Ltd.

MLS #

22046609

Source

MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Last Modified

Fri Jun 27 2025

Pending on

Jun 27 2025

Listed on

Mon Jun 23 2025


Property History

Loading...
Loading Map...

Garfield Park

Approximate location on a geospatial gridSouth Central Indy
Garfield Park media

Garfield Park, located just south of downtown Indianapolis, is one of the city’s most established neighborhoods, centered around the expansive 128-acre park that shares its name. The park itself offers a range of amenities, including walking trails, athletic courts, a conservatory, the Sunken Gardens, and the MacAllister Amphitheater, which hosts live concerts and community festivals. The neighborhood is also connected by the Pleasant Run Trail and the Cultural Trail, offering access to the rest of the city by foot or bike. With its mix of recreational space and historic infrastructure, Garfield Park has long served as a destination for both residents and visitors alike.

The community plays an active role in shaping neighborhood life. The Garfield Park Neighborhood Association organizes volunteer efforts through various committees, and local businesses like Garfield Brewery often host events and clean-up days to support public spaces. Seasonal highlights include the Garfield Park Farmers Market, Saturday yoga in the gardens, and numerous festivals and concerts throughout the year. Creative energy is also a key part of the neighborhood identity—institutions like the Garfield Park Arts Center and Big Car Collaborative bring arts programming, exhibits, and public events that foster local engagement.

Local restaurants and businesses, such as Greiner’s, Porky’s Pizza, and Shelby Street Saloon, offer long-standing neighborhood staples, while new additions continue to emerge along Shelby Street and throughout the area. Garfield Brewery has become a hub for casual gatherings and community events since its opening in 2018. From murals and arts events to concerts and public gardens, Garfield Park offers a well-rounded and highly engaged neighborhood experience with easy access to downtown Indianapolis.

Neighborhood Features

Icon
Adventures
in Nature
Icon
Established
Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Icon
Trail Access
Loading nearby neighborhoods...