421 W 44th Street
 More Photos

421 W 44th StreetIndianapolis, IN 46208


Active
$329,900 $10K
$319,900
Asking Price
2
Bd
1
Ba
1,746
Sqft
0.15
Ac Lot

421 W 44th Street Indianapolis, IN 46208


Single Family Property Type
39 daysTime on Dwellane
$189Price per sqft
2 carsGarage
1925Year Built
BasementUnfinished
An adorable English Tudor tastefully restored with modern updates in kitchen and bath. This home is a 2 bd, 1 bath w/flex room off of second bd. New roof/decking. All new flooring and the kitchen and bath are all new as well. The tub is original. Private back yard and the garage is custom built w/ 20 amp service. Designed by owners and built by Coach House in 2018.

Approximate location on a geospatial gridNorth Central Indy
Icon
Historic
Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Icon
Arts &
Culture
Buyer Blueprint

The plan that gets you home.

Learn More

Year Built

1925

City

Indianapolis

Type

Single Family Residence

Neighborhood

Butler-Tarkington

County

Marion

Lot Size

0.15 ac / 6,360 sqft

Bedrooms

2

Full Bathrooms

1

Half Bathrooms

0

Garage Capacity

2

Living Area Total

1,746 sqft

Price per sqft

$188.95

Living Area Main & Upper

996 sqft

Dwellane Agents

Ready to take the
next step?

Connect with a trusted Dwellane Agent to learn more or make an offer.

Listing Agent

Jeff Gilliam
317-691-0966

Listing Provider

Keller Williams Indy Metro NE

MLS #

22035274

Source

MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Last Modified

Tue May 13 2025

Listed on

Tue May 06 2025


Property History

Loading...
Loading Map...

Schools

Loading...

Butler-Tarkington

Approximate location on a geospatial gridNorth Central Indy
Butler-Tarkington media

Located between Meridian-Kessler and Rocky Ripple, Butler-Tarkington is home to one of the city’s most iconic institutions: Butler University. The presence of the university shapes much of the neighborhood’s character, with cultural offerings like Clowes Memorial Hall, year-round sporting events, and scenic spots like Holcomb Gardens open to the public. Butler-Tarkington also borders key thoroughfares and sits just five miles north of Monument Circle, giving residents easy access to downtown while maintaining a close-knit, walkable feel.

The area’s mix of classic homes, tree-lined streets, and neighborhood retail hubs offers both residential comfort and local convenience. Residents can find coffee shops, bookstores, and restaurants at the 56th & Illinois corridor — home to Lunch Money Boutique, Kids Ink Children’s Bookstore, and Byrne’s Grilled Pizza. Recreational options include The Riviera Club, with its pools and tennis courts, and the nearby Central Canal Towpath, a popular route for running, biking, and dog walking. Tarkington Park also serves as a community hub, offering an updated playground, splash pad, café, and regular events.

Civic pride runs deep in Butler-Tarkington, thanks in part to one of the city's longest-running neighborhood associations. From local events to walkable access to cultural and outdoor amenities, this neighborhood offers a balanced lifestyle that appeals to longtime residents and newcomers alike. With connections to Broad Ripple and an active community life supported by institutions like the Martin Luther King Community Center, Butler-Tarkington remains a cornerstone of Midtown living in Indianapolis.

Neighborhood Features

Icon
Historic
Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Icon
Arts &
Culture
Icon
Unique
Architecture