434 E New York Street
 More Photos

434 E New York StreetIndianapolis, IN 46202


Active
$1,089,000 $114K
$975,000
Asking Price
4
Bd
4
Ba
3,523
Sqft
1,781
Sqft Lot

434 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN 46202


Single Family Property Type
73 daysTime on Dwellane
$309Price per sqft
1 carGarage
1885Year Built
Basement
Step into a piece of Indianapolis history with this stunning 1885 home nestled in the highly sought-after Lockerbie Square neighborhood. Boasting a perfect blend of historic character and modern updates, this home offers an exceptional lifestyle. Located within walking distance to downtown Indianapolis, you'll enjoy easy access to the vibrant Mass Ave district, filled with unique restaurants, trendy bars, and a thriving cultural scene. This home offers endless possibilities, whether you're looking for a personal residence, a live-work space with a small office, or an investment property ideal for AirBnB or VRBO. Recently renovated with meticulous attention to detail, the home features beautifully refinished original hardwood floors, a brand-new kitchen, and updated fixtures throughout. The main floor has been thoughtfully designed to maximize functionality and convenience, including a spacious utility room that makes everyday living a breeze. Whether you're storing household items, doing laundry, or using the space for another purpose, it adds incredible value and versatility to the home. A newly installed full bath on the upper floor provides added comfort and convenience, making the layout perfect for guests or easy living. The dry basement offers ample storage space, making it both functional and convenient. A charming one-car garage adds to the property's appeal while fitting perfectly with the character of the area. The fully renovated 3rd level apartment features a separate entry and is an income producing unit. Embrace the convenience and charm of urban living in one of Indianapolis' most desirable neighborhoods. Don't miss your chance to own this exceptional property with so many uses and opportunities!

Approximate location on a geospatial gridCentral Indy
Icon
Unique
Architecture
Icon
Historic
Icon
Arts &
Culture
Buyer Blueprint

The plan that gets you home.

Learn More

Year Built

1885

City

Indianapolis

Type

Single Family Residence

Neighborhood

Lockerbie Square

County

Marion

Lot Size

0.04 ac / 1,781 sqft

Bedrooms

4

Full Bathrooms

3

Half Bathrooms

1

Garage Capacity

1

Living Area Total

3,523 sqft

Price per sqft

$309.11

Living Area Main & Upper

3,030 sqft

Dwellane Agents

Ready to take the
next step?

Connect with a trusted Dwellane Agent to learn more or make an offer.

Listing Agent

Candace Fisk
317-710-2633

Co-Listing Agent

Mark Hartman
317-691-3295

Listing Provider

Coldwell Banker - Kaiser

MLS #

22030439

Source

MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Last Modified

Wed Jun 04 2025

Listed on

Mon Apr 07 2025


Property History

Loading...
Loading Map...

Schools

Loading...

Lockerbie Square

Approximate location on a geospatial gridCentral Indy
Lockerbie Square media

Located just northeast of Downtown Indianapolis and adjacent to fellow historic districts Chatham-Arch and Cottage Home, Lockerbie Square is renowned for its well-preserved Victorian-era architecture, tree-lined streets, and charming atmosphere. Originally developed in the mid-19th century, Lockerbie Square is one of the oldest neighborhoods in Indianapolis and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The neighborhood features a mix of architectural styles, including Italianate, Federal, and Queen Anne, among others, showcasing the rich heritage of the area. Many of the homes in Lockerbie Square have been meticulously restored, contributing to the neighborhood's picturesque aesthetic.

The area also offers many things to do, as Lockerbie Square is within walking distance of downtown attractions like the Indiana War Memorial and Monument Circle, as well as local favorites like Mesh, Chatham Tap, and the Bottleworks development. With its historic charm, architectural beauty, and convenient location, Lockerbie Square offers a unique blend of old-world elegance and modern urban living.

Neighborhood Features

Icon
Unique
Architecture
Icon
Historic
Icon
Arts &
Culture
Icon
Foodie
Favorites