4751 Payton Avenue
 More Photos

4751 Payton AvenueLawrence, IN 46226


Sold
$165,000
Sale Price (listed for $165K)
3
Bd
1
Ba
864
Sqft
0.16
Ac Lot

4751 Payton Avenue Lawrence, IN 46226


Single Family Property Type
4 daysTime since sold
$191Price per sqft
2 carsGarage
1952Year Built
Affordable, adorable bungalow home with large fenced in yard in wonderful community near Ft. Harrison State Park, and just minutes from I-465 on Indy's Northeast side. Charming mid-century quality and architectural features include: hardwood floors (including under living room carpet), beautiful custom made wood doors, a very efficient, functional floorplan that is packed with practicality in a small footprint. Efficient kitchen design incorporates washer/dryer beneath counters like you'll see in many European kitchens, plus floor to ceiling wall of cabinets for additional storage. 2 largest bedrooms accommodate queen sized bed plus plenty of room for dressers, shelving, etc. The smaller bedroom would be excellent nursery or office or twin sized bedroom and offers its own closet and a view of the private back yard. OVERSIZED 2 car detached garage with 4' side extension and service door provide overflow for a man cave, hosting holiday parties and special events, and for additional storage and workspace. GENEROUS fenced in back yard once included an above ground pool, recreation area and garden. Roof is 9 years old and furnace/ac/water heater are even newer. BUDGET FRIENDLY: Citizens Gas budget is $36/mo. DON'T miss your opportunity to own a home in this highly-desirable neighborhood which is being revitalized in every direction and is walkable to nearby parks, restaurants and shopping, plus bike-able to Ft. Harrison's many amenities. EXCELLENT Lawrence Township Schools. Community Little League fields nearby, also.

Approximate location on a geospatial gridNortheast Indy
Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Icon
Suburban
Living
Icon
Lakeside
Living
Buyer Blueprint

The plan that gets you home.

Learn More

Year Built

1952

City

Lawrence

Type

Single Family Residence

Neighborhood

Lawrence Township

County

Marion

Lot Size

0.16 ac / 7,100 sqft

Bedrooms

3

Full Bathrooms

1

Half Bathrooms

0

Garage Capacity

2

Living Area Total

864 sqft

Price per sqft

$190.97

Living Area Main & Upper

864 sqft

Dwellane Agents

Ready to take the
next step?

Connect with a trusted Dwellane Agent to learn more or make an offer.

Listing Agent

Tracey Nix
317-529-9566

Buyer Agent

Ana Tibbott
317-366-1277

Listing Provider

Nix Real Estate Group

MLS #

22041883

Source

MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Last Modified

Fri Jun 13 2025

Sold on

Jun 13 2025

Listed on

Thu May 29 2025


Property History

Loading...
Loading Map...

Lawrence Township

Approximate location on a geospatial gridNortheast Indy
Lawrence Township media

Lawrence Township, just northeast of Indianapolis, offers a seamless blend of history, nature, and suburban convenience. At its core is Fort Benjamin Harrison, a former military base transformed into a thriving hub of culture and outdoor recreation. The adjacent Fort Harrison State Park provides miles of scenic trails, a public golf course, and the Museum of 20th Century Warfare, preserving the area’s rich military heritage. Nearby, Skiles Test Nature Park offers a tranquil escape, while Geist Reservoir invites residents to enjoy water activities and picturesque views.

This community is known for its welcoming atmosphere and strong sense of local pride. The Fort Ben Cultural Campus has become a center for arts, music, and entertainment, featuring the Theater at the Fort, public art installations, and even the world’s first permanent Musical Swings, where movement creates harmonized melodies. Local businesses thrive here, with spots like Triton Brewing Company, Porter Books & Bread, and a diverse array of restaurants showcasing flavors from around the world.

Lawrence also values green spaces and connectivity, with paved trails linking the township to Indianapolis, including the Fall Creek Trail. The city has embraced cycling with the Tour Lawrence bike-share program, making outdoor exploration more accessible. Whether it’s attending annual festivals like Fiesta Lawrence or Winterfest, enjoying community movie nights, or simply soaking in the suburban-urban balance, Lawrence Township continues to attract those looking for a place that feels like home.

Neighborhood Features

Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Icon
Suburban
Living
Icon
Lakeside
Living
Icon
Family
Fun