519 Sutherland Avenue
 More Photos

519 Sutherland AvenueIndianapolis, IN 46205


Active
$400,000 $5K
$395,000
Asking Price
4
Bd
3
Ba
2,400
Sqft
2,831
Sqft Lot

519 Sutherland Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46205


Single Family Property Type
25 daysTime on Dwellane
$167Price per sqft
2 carsGarage
1900Year Built
$225Paid Annually
Welcome to this beautifully restored home in the heart of Fall Creek Place, ideally located on historic Sutherland Avenue. Originally built in 1900 and completely renovated in 2015, this property offers the character of the past with the thoughtful updates today's homeowners appreciate. The main floor features an open-concept layout with 9-foot ceilings, original hardwood floors, and stunning exposed brick and trim work throughout. The chef's kitchen includes a large center island, tall upper cabinets, a gas range with double oven, and built-in bench seating with storage-perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A main floor office provides a quiet space for work, or can easily be converted into a fourth bedroom. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite includes a walk-in closet, ensuite bath, and a large walkout deck ideal for relaxing or enjoying your morning coffee. Two additional guest bedrooms and a full hallway bath with a tub complete the second level. The large attic offers additional potential-ready to be finished for even more living space. Out front, enjoy the charm of a wide, covered porch and updated, low-maintenance landscaping. Out back, the fully fenced yard features a generous deck and private access to an insulated two-car garage. Additional updates include a new HVAC system (2021), exterior paint (2024), and fresh interior paint (2025). Just minutes from downtown Indianapolis, Broad Ripple, Keystone, Goose the Market, and more. A rare opportunity to own a thoughtfully updated historic home in one of Indy's most desirable neighborhoods.

Approximate location on a geospatial gridCentral Indy
Icon
Historic
Icon
Arts &
Culture
Icon
Unique
Architecture
Buyer Blueprint

The plan that gets you home.

Learn More

Year Built

1900

City

Indianapolis

Type

Single Family Residence

Neighborhood

Fall Creek Place

County

Marion

Lot Size

0.07 ac / 2,831 sqft

Bedrooms

4

Full Bathrooms

2

Half Bathrooms

1

Garage Capacity

2

Living Area Total

2,400 sqft

Price per sqft

$166.67

Living Area Main & Upper

1,656 sqft

Connect with a Dwellane Agent

Like what you see? Our trusted agents are ready to help you take the next step.

Listing Agent

Katelyn Tarr
317-410-7193

Listing Provider

Luxcity Realty

MLS #

22046006

Source

MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Last Modified

Fri Jul 11 2025

Listed on

Thu Jun 19 2025


Property History

Loading...
Loading Map...

Schools

Loading...

Fall Creek Place

Approximate location on a geospatial gridCentral Indy
Fall Creek Place media

Fall Creek Place is a downtown Indianapolis neighborhood located just two miles north of Monument Circle, offering a mix of housing options in a walkable, bike-friendly setting. The area includes a blend of historic homes and newer construction, with properties ranging widely in price and style. Since 2001, the neighborhood has seen significant investment and redevelopment through a public-private initiative led by the City of Indianapolis and King Park Development Corporation. The area is now home to more than 400 households, with continued expansion underway. Residents enjoy proximity to downtown amenities, local businesses, parks, and trail systems that support an active lifestyle.

The neighborhood's location puts it within minutes of Mass Ave, the Monon Trail, and major employment and cultural destinations like Methodist Hospital, IUPUI, and the Indianapolis Cultural Trail. Local favorites include Goose the Market, Mashcraft Brewing, Gather 22, Bocca, and Baby's, as well as fitness studios and salons. Four neighborhood parks and nearby access to the Fall Creek Greenway encourage time outdoors, while streetscape upgrades — like new sidewalks, street lighting, and buried utilities — have contributed to its transformation into a connected and pedestrian-friendly place to live.

Fall Creek Place supports a strong sense of community with regular events such as neighborhood cleanups, seasonal celebrations, and block-wide yard sales. An active homeowners association and neighborhood patrol program contribute to resident engagement. With home prices ranging from under $100,000 to over $500,000 and a mix of income levels and housing types, Fall Creek Place reflects an intentional focus on inclusive development. The neighborhood continues to evolve, blending city living with residential character and expanding green space in a historic area of Indianapolis.

Neighborhood Features

Icon
Historic
Icon
Arts &
Culture
Icon
Unique
Architecture
Icon
Parks &
Playgrounds
Loading nearby neighborhoods...