My Sugar Pie

Restaurant$$

More Photos

Loading Map...

Years of baking pies for friends and family led Kelly to follow a dream and start ‘My Sugar Pie’-the same nickname she and her mom had given to her children. Kelly is known by many to be a dedicated mother and a loving wife. Her wonderful pies and friendly disposition have combined with her entrepreneurial spirit to be a recipe for success. Kelly learned the craft of pie baking from her mom, Marge McLain who is an inspiration and constant support.

Address40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077

Phone1 (317) 733-8717

Websitewww.mysugarpie.com

ServingPies

Like what you see in
Downtown Zionsville?

Connect with a trusted Dwellane Agent to
learn more and find your perfect home.

Downtown Zionsville

Northern Suburbs

Downtown Zionsville centers around its iconic brick-paved Main Street, where historic architecture, local boutiques, and independently owned restaurants create a small-town atmosphere just minutes from suburban growth. This walkable district is the heart of Zionsville’s charm and character, offering a unique blend of old and new. Residents can enjoy a cup of coffee at a sidewalk café, browse local galleries and shops, or attend seasonal festivals that draw visitors from across Central Indiana.

The area surrounding downtown features a mix of classic homes, renovated properties, and newer infill developments that preserve the neighborhood’s traditional aesthetic. Many streets are lined with mature trees, and front porches still serve as gathering spaces. The layout encourages walking and biking, with quick access to the Zionsville Rail Trail, Lincoln Park, and public spaces like Elm Street Green. While housing tends to be more compact and established compared to other parts of Zionsville, the convenience and community atmosphere are key draws.

Living in downtown Zionsville means being close to everything the town has to offer—from summer concerts in the park to local holiday markets and art walks. Residents appreciate the ease of strolling to dinner, catching a show at the Zionsville Performing Arts Center, or grabbing fresh produce at the weekly farmers market. For those looking for a connected lifestyle with a strong sense of place, downtown offers a distinctively local experience in the heart of town.

Neighborhood Features

Arts &
Culture

Unique
Architecture

Walkable

Foodie
Favorites

Explore the Neighborhood

Loading nearby places...

Loading nearby neighborhoods...

My Sugar Pie

Like what you see inDowntown Zionsville?

Like what you see in
Downtown Zionsville?