Cottingham Estates

Cottingham Estates is an established neighborhood in West Fishers, with homes dating back to 1971. Known for its spacious lots and mature trees, the community offers a relaxed, residential feel with the added benefit of no homeowners association—giving residents more freedom and flexibility in their property use.

The neighborhood is conveniently located near a wide range of local attractions and amenities. Just minutes away, you'll find the Indy Fuel Tank, Conner Prairie, and Harrison Thompson Park for recreation, as well as entertainment and dining options like Pinheads & Alley’s Alehouse, 1933 Lounge by St. Elmo, and Fishers Test Kitchen.

With its long-standing character, prime location, and easygoing lifestyle, Cottingham Estates remains a desirable option in West Fishers.

The eastern edge of West Fishers connects directly to downtown Fishers, bringing residents close to one of the city’s most active and fast-growing districts. This area offers a mix of established neighborhoods, parks, and convenient access to shopping, dining, and entertainment. The Nickel Plate District, located near downtown, serves as a central destination with local restaurants, boutique shops, and live performances at the Nickel Plate Amphitheater. The Nickel Plate Trail also runs through this part of the city, providing a popular route for walking, biking, and connecting with nearby neighborhoods.

To the west, West Fishers reaches the White River, offering scenic views and access to riverfront green space. A key landmark in the area is Conner Prairie, a nationally recognized living history museum that hosts interactive exhibits and annual events like the Headless Horseman and Jupiter Flights Balloon Festival. From cultural attractions and outdoor recreation to well-connected roadways and expanding amenities, West Fishers brings together many of the elements that define the broader Fishers community.